Staten Island Chuck: How Often New York's Groundhog Gets Spring Right
Graded against New York's own March, Staten Island Chuck in Staten Island, New York City has been right 13 of 22 years since 2000.
Staten Island Chuck's 2027 call
Right 13 of 22 years (59 percent), against New York's March and its 20th century average.
- 13 of 22right since 2000
- Shadowin 2026, wrong
- 14 of 22calling early spring every year
- 85%on NOAA’s national scorecard
Photo: “Groundhog (48935342271)”, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Midwest Region, Public domain
Every Staten Island Chuck call since 2000
A shadow is right when New York's March comes in colder than its 20th century average; no shadow is right when it comes in warmer.
| Year | Call | March in New York | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2027 | Feb 2 | ||
| 2026 | Shadow | 5.0° warmer | Wrong |
| 2025 | No shadow | 6.4° warmer | Right |
| 2024 | No shadow | 6.9° warmer | Right |
| 2023 | No shadow | 2.0° warmer | Right |
| 2022 | No shadow | 3.2° warmer | Right |
| 2021 | No shadow | 4.4° warmer | Right |
| 2020 | No shadow | 6.6° warmer | Right |
| 2019 | No shadow | 1.1° colder | Wrong |
| 2018 | No shadow | 0.7° colder | Wrong |
| 2017 | No shadow | 2.4° colder | Wrong |
2000 to 2016
| Year | Call | March in New York | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2016 | No shadow | 7.1° warmer | Right |
| 2015 | No shadow | 5.1° colder | Wrong |
| 2014 | Shadow | 7.0° colder | Right |
| 2013 | No shadow | exactly average | Neither |
| 2012 | No shadow | 12.7° warmer | Right |
| 2011 | No shadow | 0.3° warmer | Right |
| 2010 | No shadow | 7.6° warmer | Right |
| 2009 | No shadow | 2.5° warmer | Right |
| 2008 | No shadow | 1.3° colder | Wrong |
| 2007 | No shadow | 0.4° colder | Wrong |
| 2006 | No shadow | 1.1° warmer | Right |
| 2005 | No shadow | 3.0° colder | Wrong |
| 2000 | Shadow | 7.3° warmer | Wrong |
What NOAA’s outlook says for New York
NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center outlook for February to April 2027, issued November 19, 2026, leans warmer in New York, with 50 percent odds of a warmer than normal February to April. A shadow agrees with a lean colder and no shadow with a lean warmer.
So on Feb 2: a shadow, and Staten Island Chuck parts ways with NOAA; no shadow, and the two agree.
CPC issues a new outlook on the third Thursday of each month, and the January outlook is the last before Groundhog Day. The full picture, with the snowpack and frost dates, is on the New York spring forecast.
Staten Island Chuck in Staten Island, New York City
Staten Island Chuck calls from Staten Island, New York City on Tuesday, February 2, hosted by the Staten Island Zoo. New York City's forecaster tops NOAA's own ranking of the forecasters with twenty years of calls.
Every other forecaster in New York
- Dunkirk Dave, Dunkirkright 14 of 26 since 2000
- Holtsville Hal, Holtsvilleright 9 of 26 since 2000
- Malverne Mel, Malverneright 10 of 26 since 2000
- Buffalo Bert, Buffaloright 5 of 13 since 2013
Punxsutawney Phil, graded against New York's March instead of Pennsylvania’s, has been right 11 of 26 years since 2000. Staten Island Chuck has the better record here.
How Staten Island Chuck is graded
Each call is set against New York's average March temperature from NOAA’s statewide records, the rule NOAA uses for its own scorecard against the whole contiguous US (2006 to 2025). A March exactly on its average counts neither way, and the 2027 call is graded in April, once NOAA publishes March.
March 2026 in New York came in 5.0 degrees warmer than its 20th century average, the 18th warmest March since 1895. Since 2000, March has come in warmer than average in 17 of 27 years.
